Best Italian food in Oconomowoc

Family-Owned Italian Restaurant | Fresh Seafood, Bold Flavors

Try our most popular items

Treat yourself to our must-try list that has everyone talking

View Full Menu

Ricotta Gnocchi

Italian sausage, and spinach, tossed in a dolce gorgonzola cream

Add Item

Swordfish

Grilled swordfish with tomato salmoriglio sauce, Roman potatoes, and garlic spinach

Add Item

Branzino

Roasted skin-on Mediterranean sea bass, caramelized fennel, spinach and currants, saffron risotto, and limoncello caper sauce

Add Item

Lamb

Grilled Pinn-Oak ridge lamb lollipops, garlic mashed potatoes, asparagus, and Verde sauce

Add Item

Beef Short Ribs

Nero d'Avola-braised beef short rib, garlic mashed potatoes, green beans, roasted parmigiano tomato

Add Item

Chocolate Mousse Dome (GF)

Chocolate Mousse with Chantilly Cream, Flourless Chocolate cake, Toasted Hazelnuts, Chocolate Ganache and Berry Compote.

Add Item
Welcome to Lago Su Bella

Welcome to Lago Su Bella

As a longtime, local restaurateur and former owner (Michael) of the beloved Bertrand’s Point Comfort on Okauchee Lake, my wife, Lani, and I are delighted to introduce our authentic & exclusively-Italian ristorante to the shores of Lac La Belle. Lago Su Bella ~ translated to on a beautiful lake in Italian ~ offers stunning lake views, and a menu that emulates & is inspired by the amazing diversity of Italy’s eclectic culinary scene.

Television Feature

Television Feature
We’re excited to announce that Lago Su Bella has been featured on America’s Best Restaurants! This exclusive episode takes you behind the scenes of our ristorante, showcasing the passion and dedication that goes into every dish we serve. Don’t miss the chance to see what makes us a standout destination for authentic Italian cuisine.
Check feature

Easy Dining Options

Easy Dining Options
Our menu features fresh seafood, bright sauces, and homemade pasta, along with lighter fare and small plates. We source the finest fish and local, seasonal ingredients, changing the menu regularly to reflect the best of each season. Inspired by Italy’s social dining culture, we invite you to connect at our open-seating table or enjoy a drink at our spacious bar, all while taking in the sights and aromas from our open kitchen. We look forward to serving you a delightful taste of Italy.

Reservations

Reservations
Reservations are available 14 days in advance. Currently, we are only accepting tables up to 6 guests. A portion of our bar and dining room tables are held nightly for walk-in diners. 📌If you are running late, please call the restaurant at 262-354-3440. We will hold a reserved table for a grace period of 15 minutes before offering the reservation to our waitlist.
Reserve

Fresh, Flavorful Meals

Our menu features homemade pasta, fresh seafood, and tasty small plates. Our seafood is never frozen, brought in fresh to us every day, ensuring top quality and flavor in every bite. Whether you want something light or hearty, we’ve got you covered.

Come Visit Us

Come Visit Us
Whether you’re a local or just passing through, we’d love to have you at Lago Su Bella. Order online or come by today for a great meal. We can’t wait to see you! 🍽️🍝

What our customers are saying

Check out our most recent reviews!

A taste of Italy. We went on a Thursday night. It was busy but not hectic. The bartender took good care of us, he even let us benefit from happy hour prices with two minutes to spare. Our table was in the main dining room which is bathed in natural sunlight. The waitress was friendly and efficient. My sea bass and my wife’s spaghetti brought back memories of our recent trip to Italy. We look forward to visiting again.

Peter F.

Peter F.

My group went to celebrate birthdays and the service was great! They even got us a special table by the window and set it up to accommodate disabilities within our group.

Kayla S.

Kayla S.

Was really impressed with all the food that we ordered from the appetizers all the way to the desserts. Every item was so rich and delicious. The service as well was so unbelievably kind and helpful. The only negative was that it was really loud in there which isn’t what I expected from a spendy place. There’s no soft textures anywhere to “soak up” the noise; it’s a lot of mirrors and glass and brick so it just gets really, really loud which was an atmosphere bummer. Once some tables left it was more manageable and enjoyable.

Paul D.

Paul D.

Featuring

Catering

Delivery

Takeout

Curbside Pickup

Dine In

Reservations

Frequently asked questions

Our location